Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Andrew K's avatar

Great read. Great take. Way to hang those balls out. I see the timeline as somewhere between tomorrow and January '28. CapEx borrowing vs. Treasury borrowing is a car crash in the offing. Sustained 4.8% 10 year Treasuries will kill companies with huge refinancing obligations. We're almost there. A few AI winners. A nation full of empty wallets.

craazyman's avatar

Totally agree (which given my track record should make us all uneasy! LOL)

At any rate, it's hard to know if you're "early" or "wrong".

I spent last week & weekend doing a deep dive (for me) into AI bubble thesis. I can't convince myself it's anything else.

The "AI Field of Dreams (Build it and they will come)" needs enormous profitable inference demand to justify the planned compute build. It has to come from consumers or business. If I do the numbers I can't get there either way. Its' so far short it's incredible. And the way to force it there is to assume: 1) consumers spend more on AI than on most of their entertainment combined or 2) business AI use explodes with agentic systems, which comes hand in hand with massive job losses. And even inference volume isn't enough, it has to be profitable volume. And inference prices are falling like rocks out of Galileo's leaning tower.

Already there's cultural AI revulsion taking form -- "AI slop" backlash and corporate employee resistance. Business use of AI at Field of Dreams level isn't a slam dunk.

It's technical, but LLMs have severe limitations as algorithms for artificial general intelligence (AGI). In short, they're mistake prone at a mathematical level that's impossible to fix. For fun and consumer use, whatever. For serious business use? Watch out.

That's not to say they're useless. I know enough about LLMs and programming to understand the tech-world fanboy energy. It's incredible to see your computer "do things" -- read/write files, web surf, "reason", code, write good prose -- on its own. Smart people (defined narrowly) can extrapolate their enthusiasm beyond reason. Or they can overthink and under-realize: Isaac Newton himself lost money in S. Sea Bubble.

To me, it all comes back to profitable inference rising to levels that I just can't see with any lucid thinking. From consumers? From business? It just doesn't pencil out, IMHO. When does that dream break down? I don't know but I agree it will.

41 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?